American CEOs used to ask one question: “Did we beat last quarter’s numbers?”
In 2025, the question is shifting to:“Did we create value for people, planet, and profit — and can we prove it?”
In a year of political polarization, worker burnout, and economic uncertainty, how American businesses define “success” is becoming a national competitiveness issue. Companies that cling to old metrics risk losing talent, customers, and investor confidence. Those that adapt are quietly building a new playbook for the American economy.
Story 1: From “Shareholder First” to “Stakeholder First”
For decades, success in corporate America meant one thing: maximizing shareholder value. Today, more boards are asking how to serve employees, customers, communities, and the environment — not just investors.
In 2019, the Business Roundtable, representing 181 of America’s largest companies, issued a landmark statement redefining the purpose of a corporation: to serve all stakeholders, not only shareholders. That shift set the tone for a broader transformation in U.S. business ethics and strategy, echoed by ongoing discussions around stakeholder capitalism.
By 2024, nearly three-quarters of S&P 500 companies were tying parts of executive incentives to ESG metrics — environmental, social, and governance — signaling that performance is no longer purely financial.
New definition of success: “We win when our shareholders succeed because our people, communities, and environment are doing better — not in spite of them.”
Story 2: The B Corp Boom — Profit and Purpose
Another powerful signal of transformation is the rise of B Corps — companies legally committed to balancing profit and purpose.
According to B Lab’s 2024/2025 reporting, B Corp certifications grew by over 16% in the U.S. and Canada in a single year, with thousands of companies now meeting rigorous social and environmental standards. Roughly a quarter of all certified B Corps worldwide are in the U.S. and Canada, and brand awareness is rising: among Americans who know the label, 86% say they trust B Corps and see the standards as rigorous.
Well-known U.S. B Corps include Patagonia, Etsy, and Veeva Systems, often cited as influential examples of combining strong financial performance with climate action, fair labor, and ethical governance.
New definition of success: “We’re not just a brand you buy from; we’re a business you believe in.”
-
New success metric: Revenue + employee retention + community investment + carbon reduction.
-
Outcome: Higher employee loyalty, easier recruiting, stronger customer trust — and still profitable.
Story 3: Redefining Success at Work — The 4-Day Week & Human-Centered Productivity
If success used to mean “more hours, more hustle,” 2025 is challenging that logic.
A recent survey from the American Psychological Association shows that by 2024, 22% of U.S. workers said their employer offered a four-day workweek, up from 14% in 2022. Research on 4-day week pilots finds that with clear expectations and well-designed experiments, companies can maintain or even improve productivity and retention while reducing burnout.
New definition of success: “We measure productivity by outcomes, not hours — and by whether people can thrive, not just survive.”
-
Problem: High burnout, quiet quitting, rising turnover in U.S. companies.
-
Experiment: 6-month 4-day workweek pilot with no pay cut; teams redesign workflows and prioritize deep work.
-
Results (typical from global pilots):
-
Productivity maintained or improved
-
Reduced stress, improved mental health
-
Lower turnover intention and easier hiring
-
Story 4: When Executive Pay Follows Impact, Not Just EPS
In many boardrooms, the ultimate sign of what matters is what determines executive bonuses.
That’s why one of the most significant — though often under-reported — shifts in American business is the integration of ESG and impact metrics into executive pay.
A 2024 study found that about 81% of global companies and nearly three-quarters of S&P 500 firms now include at least one ESG measure in executive incentive plans, often tied to climate targets, worker safety, diversity and inclusion, or customer satisfaction.
Even amid political backlash against ESG in parts of the U.S., companies are refining rather than abandoning these metrics — making them more measurable, more connected to strategy, and more transparent to shareholders.
New definition of success: “Leaders are rewarded when they grow the business and keep their promises to people and planet.”
Example impact metrics linked to pay
-
Reducing workplace injuries or serious safety incidents
-
Lowering greenhouse-gas emissions intensity
-
Increasing representation of under-represented groups in leadership
-
Improving customer satisfaction or net promoter scores
-
Progress on data privacy or cyber-security readiness
Story 5: From “Quarterly Wins” to “Long-Term Transformation”
Finally, there’s a deeper narrative emerging: success is becoming a long-term, systemic concept.
Recent reports highlight a global shift toward values like care, resilience, and long-term value creation — what some call “caring companies” and others frame as a new generation of stakeholder capitalism.
At the same time, the B Corp movement’s growth, the continued seriousness of sustainability commitments, and the integration of social impact into business models signal that many organizations are no longer content with cosmetic CSR projects.
New definition of success: “Did we make this quarter — and did we make this decade better for the people and places we touch?”
Transformation mindset in practice
-
Investing in reskilling and upskilling instead of just layoffs
-
Building resilient supply chains instead of ultra-lean but fragile ones
-
Collaborating with communities, NGOs, and public institutions on shared problems
-
Using data and geomapping to understand who benefits — and who is left behind
How America Wins When We Redefine Success
When you put all five stories together, a pattern emerges:
-
Stakeholders, not just shareholders, are at the center.
-
Impact is being measured — and tied to leadership incentives.
-
Work is being redesigned around humans, not just output.
-
Profit and purpose are becoming partners, not enemies.
-
Time horizons are stretching from quarters to decades.
This isn’t just a moral shift. It’s strategic. Companies with strong ESG practices and clear purpose increasingly show more resilience, higher employee engagement, and stronger brand trust — advantages that matter in an era of disruption.
Join the Discussion: Shape the Future of American Business
If you’re a CEO, executive, policymaker, entrepreneur, or community leader, you are part of this story.
At American Transformation Forum (ATF), we convene leaders across sectors to:
-
Share real-world transformation case studies
-
Explore new metrics and models of success
-
Co-create strategies for a more resilient, inclusive American economy
Join the American Transformation Conversation
Ready to help redefine what success looks like for American businesses in 2025 and beyond?
Sign up for an ATF Council or Forum to connect with leaders who are piloting new models of success.
Share this article with your team and ask: “How are we redefining success?”
Comment with your own transformation story — your company could be featured in our next spotlight.
- Also read: Navigating the TikTok Ban Debate: Balancing Economic Growth, National Security, and Digital TransformationCheck out the GTF Research
Check out events
Connect with us on facebook
connect with us on linkedIn
Check out the American Transformation forum
